If You Could Own Any Vintage Car, What Should It Be?

Imagine it’s a sunny Sunday morning. You open your garage, and sitting there is the vintage car of your dreams. Maybe it's a rumbling muscle car, a sleek European sports car, or a stylish convertible from the '50s. It’s a fantasy many classic car lovers share.

For many aficionados, owning a vintage vehicle is not just about having another mode of transportation. It’s more about having that connection to the past and owning a rolling piece of history that essentially serves as a time capsule. Classic cars effortlessly evoke nostalgia, stirring up positive emotions and fond childhood memories or reminding us of bygone eras.

For some, it's a hobby; for others, it's an investment. But at its core, the desire to own a classic car is rooted in passion, identity, and a love for timeless design.

One common question among those who fantasize about owning a classic vehicle is: if you could own any vintage car, which one should it be?

The answer is obviously different for everyone, but it ultimately depends on your personality, driving style, preferences, appreciation for automotive history, and yes—even your budget. Here, we’re going to give you some recommendations to help you discover your perfect classic ride.

What Makes a Car "Vintage"?

When we talk about vintage vehicles, we usually refer to old cars that have achieved iconic status over the years. But the term “vintage” is actually a lot more fluid depending on who you ask. Most collectors and automotive organizations consider a car vintage if it's at least 25 years old.

It’s a broad definition, which means a vehicle from the late 1990s might technically qualify as vintage, though the emotional and cultural weight of the word often leans toward older eras.

For insurance and registration purposes, many states and classic car clubs also use the 25-year mark as a baseline to grant vehicles special status, whether it’s for historical plates or eligibility for classic car shows.

Some people use the term ‘vintage’ in reference to car models that were from the 1950s to the 1980s. This is known as the golden age of design and innovation after all. These decades produced vehicles with distinctive styling, chrome-heavy exteriors, and powerful engines that defined American and European motoring culture.

From the sleek 1960s Mustang to the bold 1980s Porsche 911, these cars symbolize an era of craftsmanship, performance, and personality that's harder to find in today's more uniform automotive landscape.

Regardless of the specific definition you use, we can all agree that not every old vehicle is a “classic”.

What Should You Consider When Choosing a Vintage Car?

The decision to buy a vintage automobile is usually tied to someone’s passion and appreciation for excellent craftsmanship and unique aesthetics. But at the end of the day, this is also a financial decision, so you need to be smart about choosing your vehicle. You also need to consider what it’s actually like to own a classic vehicle before giving up your modern ride.

While these vintage vehicles can bring joy and character to your life, they also come with unique challenges:

Maintenance

Vintage cars often require more frequent and specialized care than modern vehicles. Many older models lack the reliability and ease of maintenance we take for granted today, so be prepared for routine checkups, fluid leaks, and quirks that may require a skilled mechanic or even some DIY know-how.

For many enthusiasts though, this is all part of the charm. Getting their hands dirty and really getting to know the vehicle inside out is part of the appeal. If this is not the case for you, you may have to look for someone who specializes in these older vehicles.

Parts Availability

One of the biggest hurdles with classic cars is finding the right parts. While some popular models have strong aftermarket support, others might send you hunting through swap meets, forums, or overseas suppliers. Availability can make or break the ownership experience, especially if you plan on driving your car regularly. Before buying your vintage vehicle, do your research on the availability of parts for that particular model.

Driving Experience

Don’t expect the smooth, quiet ride of a new car. Vintage vehicles can be noisy, stiff, and lacking modern conveniences like power steering, air conditioning, and advanced safety features. If you're planning to use the car beyond weekend cruises, it’s important to understand and accept the driving feel of an older machine.

Again, for some people, the sound of a vintage car adds to the unique driving experience and is part of the reason why they love it.

Resale Value

Not all classic cars are guaranteed investments. While some models appreciate in value over time, others may hold steady or even drop in resale price. Researching the market trends for specific makes and models can help you decide whether the car you're eyeing is likely to pay off—or just pay out. This is especially important if your plan is to add the vehicle to your investment portfolio.

If You Could Own Any Vintage Car, What Should It Be?

Sometimes, emotion is the most compelling reason to buy a vintage car. Maybe it’s the car your parents drove, or the one that hung as a poster on your childhood wall. That personal bond can make maintenance challenges or lack of modern features feel like part of the charm, rather than a burden.

For some people, they don’t have to look far and wide for an ideal model because they already have a dream car in mind. If you have this connection with a particular vintage vehicle, do your research on it and see if it is viable to own one today.

If you don’t have any particular model in mind, here are a few classic recommendations:

For the Speed Fanatic: 1967 Shelby GT500

If you crave speed, muscle, and that unmistakable American rumble, the 1967 Shelby GT500 delivers in spades. Built with a thundering 428-cubic-inch V8 and aggressive styling, it wasn’t just a Mustang—it was the Mustang that turned heads and tore up pavement.

With Carroll Shelby’s performance tweaks, the GT500 became a symbol of power and rebellion, making it a dream car for those who live for the roar of the engine and the thrill of the open road.

For the Europhile: 1961 Jaguar E-Type

Few cars combine elegance and performance like the 1961 Jaguar E-Type. With its long, sculpted hood, low-slung body, and race-inspired engineering, it was as fast as it was beautiful. Even Enzo Ferrari famously called it "the most beautiful car ever made," and it’s easy to see why. This model represents the pinnacle of British automotive design and remains a timeless icon for anyone with a love for European craftsmanship and style.

For the Racer at Heart: 1989 Porsche 911 Carrera

The 1989 Porsche 911 Carrera is for those who dream of apexes and redlines. It marked the end of the G-series generation and came with a refined 3.2L flat-six engine, legendary balance, and that unmistakable air-cooled Porsche sound.

Whether you’re carving up a canyon road or just admiring it in your garage, the Carrera blends daily drivability with track-ready performance, making it a top pick for the driving purist.

For the Off-Roader: 1970 Ford Bronco

If your idea of fun involves dirt trails and mountain views, the 1970 Ford Bronco is your vintage dream come true. It was designed to tackle rough terrain with ease.

This model combined classic 4x4 capability with a simple, boxy style that has since aged beautifully. As one of the most beloved off-roaders of its era, the early Bronco is a rugged and reliable companion for anyone with a sense of adventure.

For the Nostalgic Driver: 1957 Chevrolet Bel Air

Chrome, fins, and all-American swagger—the 1957 Chevrolet Bel Air is a rolling time capsule from a golden era. With its iconic two-tone paint, wide grille, and V8 engine options, the Bel Air captured the optimism and flair of 1950s America. This is a feel-good machine that brings back memories while helping you create new ones on the road.

For the Style Seeker: 1964 Lincoln Continental Convertible

One of the biggest reasons to own a vintage vehicle is to show off its unique aesthetic—and few cars ooze style and sophistication like the 1964 Lincoln Continental Convertible. Its slab-sided design, rear suicide doors, and low-slung profile make it instantly recognizable. Add in the open-top cruising experience, and you have a ride that’s as smooth and refined as a jazz lounge.

For those who want to make a statement without saying a word, the Continental is the coolest pick out there.

For the First-Time Classic Owner: 1965–1966 Ford Mustang

Affordable, reliable, and endlessly charming, the 1965 to 1966 Ford Mustang is the perfect gateway into classic car ownership. It has a wide range of body styles and engine options so you can get a truly personalized experience—without the high cost of rarer collectibles.

It’s simple to work on, easy to find parts for, and turns heads at every turn. Overall, this is a timeless pony car that still captures the hearts of enthusiasts around the world.

Honorable Mentions

If none of the vintage cars above piqued your interest, here are a few more vintage gems worth looking into:

How to Make the Vintage Car Dream a Reality

It goes without saying that diving into the classic car world without a plan can lead to unexpected costs and headaches. Here are a few simple steps you can take to turn your dream into a more manageable, rewarding reality:

1. Set a Budget

Start by figuring out how much you can realistically spend—not just on the purchase, but on insurance, maintenance, restoration, and storage. As we mentioned earlier, classic cars can come with unique challenges, and that includes hidden costs. It’s wise to plan ahead and avoid overextending yourself financially.

2. Join Classic Car Forums

Online communities are a goldmine of information. Whether you’re a first-time buyer or a seasoned enthusiast, forums let you ask questions, get advice, learn from others’ experiences, and sometimes even find great deals on cars or parts.

3. Start Small

Your first vintage car doesn’t have to be a rare or high-dollar model. Starting with something more affordable and reliable can help you learn the ropes of ownership without overwhelming your budget or mechanical skills.

4. Check Local Auctions and Listings

Keep an eye on local listings, classic car auctions, and estate sales. These venues often offer well-kept vehicles at lower prices than dealers, and you might even find a hidden gem that’s been sitting in a garage for decades.

5. Inspect Before You Buy

Always inspect a vintage car in person, or hire a trusted mechanic to do it for you. Rust, hidden damage, and poor restoration work can turn a dream purchase into a nightmare if you’re not careful. Taking the time to inspect can save you thousands down the road.

Work with Classic Car Deals to Find the Best Classic Cars for Sale

At the end of the day, the best vintage car is the one that makes you smile. Whether it’s the thrill of a roaring V8, the sophistication of a European roadster, or the nostalgia of a classic cruiser, your ideal car is out there.

Classic Car Deals can help you find the vintage vehicle of your dreams. After all, we are the world’s largest online consignment company. Our team can help you find the classic car that matches your exact needs and preferences, whether it’s a vintage car or truck.

Classic Car Deals is located in Cadillac, Michigan and features the widest selection of well-curated classic cars (and trucks) that are available via consignment. So don’t worry if you don’t see your ideal car right away. We have consignment vehicles all over the country.

Check out our showroom to view all the consignment vehicles we personally have in stock at our headquarters. You can also go online to see all the vintage cars on our website.

Call Classic Car Deals once you’ve found your ideal classic car to double check on the location. They provide an easy and hassle-free way for you to shop classic cars for sale nationwide, offering the widest selection of vintage, exotic, and collectible cars and pickup trucks.

Your first step to buying your dream car is to contact one of our reps today. Visit the Classic Car Deals consignment page today for more details.

 

*While every reasonable effort is made to ensure the accuracy of this information, we are not responsible for any errors or omissions contained on these pages. Please verify any information in question with Dealer.